6720 S. 27th Street, Oak Creek, WI 53154

Countertops take up a lot of the visual field in a kitchen. They often compete with cabinets, flooring and even appliances as a show-stopping focal point. The countertop material to use in a kitchen is only half of an important decision.

The other half is what color countertop works best – a light color or a dark color.

There are advantages and disadvantages to both.

Should Your Countertops Contrast with Your Cabinets?

The traditional design convention has been to select a countertop color that contrasts with the cabinets, as these design elements are adjacent to each other. This would mean that if you have dark cabinets you would select a light-colored countertop and vice versa.1

Design experts have seen an emerging trend toward having the countertops closely match the cabinet color. A typical example of this would be to pair traditional painted pale colored kitchen cabinets with white or Cararra marble-style countertops.2

Should You Consider the Size of your Kitchen?

Yes, because the cabinets aren’t the whole story. You also need to take into consideration the size of your kitchen and the lighting. A smaller kitchen generally appears larger with light-colored countertops and dark countertops make a large kitchen appear homier and more welcoming.3 Having just one countertop color isn’t a rule.

If you love dark countertops but have a small kitchen you might choose to do just a section of the kitchen countertop, such as the island, in a dark color with the perimeter countertops in a light color. This combination can create visual interest.4

What About the Kitchen Lighting?

Lighting is also important. If your kitchen gets a lot of natural light coming through windows or a skylight or has excellent task lighting, dark countertops wouldn’t be a problem. If your kitchen is not well lit, dark countertops can make the space appear cave-like and gloomy.

Kitchen tasks also become harder to accomplish in low-light situations. Keys, phones and other objects on the counter blend with dark counters and are harder to locate, especially for seniors with vision issues. Dark countertops with good lighting provide drama without making the space feel too small.

Pros of Light Countertops

  • Light countertops reflect light so they help balance dark cabinets.
  • Light countertops give the illusion of space in small kitchens.
  • Light countertops brighten the kitchen, giving it a light and airy feeling.

Cons of Light Countertops

  • White kitchens with white reflective (shiny) countertops can be too bright.
  • Light countertops can be harder to keep clean and stains are more visible on light-countertops.
  • White can make a kitchen appear sterile when paired with light floors, walls and cabinets.5

Pros of Dark Countertops

  • Dark countertops add a touch of drama to a kitchen and can easily serve as a focal point in a kitchen.
  • Dark countertops can make a kitchen feel warm and cozy.
  • Dark countertops, especially those with textured surfaces, can be easier to maintain as they hide stains and wear.

Cons of Dark Countertops

  • Dark countertops absorb light, rather than reflecting it as light countertops do. This means that the kitchen can feel smaller without the benefit of good lighting.
  • Dark countertops show fingerprints, watermarks, crumbs and dust more prominently. This is especially true of shiny dark countertops. Consider a matte finish instead.6

Should You Combine Light and Dark Countertops?

One of the most effective kitchen designs may actually combine the two.

Using one countertop color on the island and another along the perimeter gives you more flexibility with the room’s proportions, cabinetry, and lighting. It can also help define different areas within an open kitchen.

The key is making sure the colors, patterns, and materials relate to one another rather than looking like two unrelated choices.

See Your Countertop Options in Person Before You Decide

Countertop color can look very different in a showroom, online, and inside your own kitchen. Cabinet color, flooring, wall finishes, natural light, and even the direction your windows face can affect how a stone or quartz surface appears.

That’s why seeing materials in person and discussing the overall kitchen design can make the selection process much easier.

Compare Countertop Colors, Materials & Finishes in Oak Creek

At Wisconsin Granite Design in Oak Creek, we help homeowners compare granite, quartz, marble, and other countertop options based on the way their kitchens actually look and function. Our team can help you evaluate colors, patterns, finishes, and material choices before moving forward with professional fabrication and countertop installation.

Visit our Oak Creek countertop showroom or contact us today to discuss your kitchen project and find a countertop that fits your space, style, and everyday needs.

_______________________________________________________________________________

1, 2, 5, 6 Should Kitchen Countertops Be Light or Dark? By Sarah Warwick, 12/27/2022
Link: https://www.homesandgardens.com/kitchens/should-kitchen-countertops-be-light-or-dark

3, 4 Light or Dark Countertops: Which Is Right For Your Kitchen? By Darby Wagler, 1/14/2023
Link: https://www.housedigest.com/1167522/light-or-dark-countertops-which-is-right-for-your-kitchen/